Heart Cookie Pops from The Decorated Cookie :: 14 Days of Sweet Valentine Ideas

The very talented Meaghan from The Decorated Cookie is sharing this adorable idea mixing traditional Conversation Hearts and a Cookie! Here are the details...

From Meaghan....

The idea of using crushed hearts to decorate cookies might be viewed as somehow contrary to the sentiment of Valentine's day, but I see it differently. Why not benefit from the wonderful array of pretty colors inside a box of conversation hearts? Just be sure to leave at least one chosen heart safe and sound and unbroken one each cookie.

you will need:*

cut-out cookie dough

royal icing

food coloring

cookie sticks

small heart cookie cutter

conversation hearts

decorating bag


size “4” decorating tip


Ziploc bag

hammer or mallet

*For food coloring, I use Americolor Soft Gel Paste (Electric Pink), available in specialty cake decorating stores or online. Find the cookie sticks, cookie cutter, decorating bag, coupler and tip in the craft store. Because the candy makes these cookies top-heavy, choose a smaller heart cutter (about 2-inches).  For chocolate cookie dough and royal icing recipe, click here:  

step one: bake your cookies

Roll out chilled cookie dough 3/8-inch thick and cut out your hearts. Insert a cookie stick in the base of the cookie, about halfway into the heart. Place on a baking tray lined with parchment paper and bake according to the recipe. Let cool completely.

step two: prepare your icing

Prepare royal icing according to the recipe. Tint any color you like. Prepare a decorating bag with coupler and size “4” decorating tip, fill with the icing, and close tightly with a rubberband.

step three: crush your hearts

Place a handful of conversation hearts in a Ziploc bag. Place on the counter over a dishtowel or cutting board and crush the hearts with the hammer or mallet. Be sure to reserve some whole hearts for decorating!

step four: decorate your cookies

Pipe an outline on the heart cookies and let set about 15 minutes. Pipe back and forth to completely fill the heart with icing. Place a whole conversation heart on the icing, then take a handful of crushed hearts and sprinkle over the heart to completely cover. Turn over the cookie to remove excess and let the cookies dry well, preferably overnight.

Look at how cute these are!!

So fun! Thank you Meaghan for sharing!!

We are super excited for the debut of Meaghan's book Sugarlicious! Watch for a fun giveaway in the next few weeks!


Related Posts


  1. Sue @ Cakeballs, cookies and more 02/08/2012

    oh those are adorable, love it!

  2. Sharleen C. 02/08/2012

    Very cute love them!

  3. Aimee 02/08/2012


  4. Sweet Treats for Valentine’s Day | Sweet City Candy 02/08/2012

    [...]  Heart Cookie Pops from The Decorated Cookie via TomKatStudio.com look so delicious.  I love the crushed conversation hearts for decorations – yumm!  Click [...]

  5. Katy 02/08/2012

    Those are a great idea! I too made some sweetheart pops but with cake that I think turned out pretty good, for a beginner! Check them out on my website, I would love to post them on here! :)

  6. shelly (cookies and cups) 02/08/2012

    I love these! LOVE!

  7. Cassi 02/09/2012

    These look perfect! I will be making them! Thank you!

  8. Carrie 02/09/2012

    These are so fun! I love the idea of leaving one heart whole... so your message comes through clearly! Thanks for sharing Meaghan!

  9. mazelmoments 02/09/2012

    What a great idea! Just in time for Valentine's day!

  10. trisha 02/10/2012

    I was JUST looking for an easy FUN idea to do with my daughter this weekend! YAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAaa Big thanks! Off to get supplies now! WHOOOOOOOOP!

  11. Sarah (Canterbury Cakes) 02/10/2012

    What a fabulous idea. I always wanted to try cake-pops but found them daunting....cookie-pops, however, seem much more manageable!

  12. Ruoka, vinkkejä | Pearltrees 04/25/2012

    [...] Heart Cookie Pops from The Decorated Cookie :: 14 Days of Sweet Valentine Ideas | The TomKat Studio Look at how cute these are!! [...]

  13. Torsdagsfavoriter « Colorfullife 04/26/2012

    [...]  Vem vill baka så här fint till mig? (länk) [...]

  14. 101 Valentines Ideas for Decor, Kids, Gifts, Treats, Desserts, Favors, Parties and More | Creative Life Of A Glam Wife 01/15/2013

    [...] Adorable~!! Instructions are here. [...]

  15. Top 10 Valentine’s Treats to make with kids! | ptpamedia.com 01/27/2013

    [...] 3.  Be Mine!  Remember those cute hearts with the sayings on them? Try smashing them to create these Heart Cookie Pops with conversation hearts! [...]

  16. 50 Sweet Conversation Heart Recipes and Crafts 02/10/2013

    [...] crushed conversation heart cookie pops {the tomkat studio} [...]

  17. Food: Sweetest Cookie Pops | Wave Avenue Wave Avenue 05/22/2013

    [...] surely melt one’s heart. Don’t you think so? Check out the Meagan’s tutorial here. And don’t forget to visit her other scrumptious works at The Decorated [...]

  18. Sweet Treats for Valentine's Day | Bulk Candy and Chocolate for Corporate Events and Parties 11/21/2013

    […]  Heart Cookie Pops from The Decorated Cookie via TomKatStudio.com look so delicious.  I love the crushed conversation hearts for decorations – yumm!  Click […]

  19. Conversation Hearts Galore 01/30/2014

    […] Heart Cookie Pops – The Tomkat Studio […]


Login or Register to comment.